A machining RFQ (request for quotation) gets you an accurate, comparable price when it carries nine things: a current drawing with its revision, a STEP model, a fully named material, tolerances on the features that matter, quantities by phase, finish, inspection requirements, packaging and delivery terms, and one named person who can answer questions. Leave any of them out and the shop either guesses, pads the price for risk, or comes back with questions that cost you days.
This checklist is written for engineers, designers, buyers and small manufacturers who are sending a part out to be cut. It also works for a dealer, race team or specialty shop sending a bracket, fixture or replacement part to a machinist.
TL;DR
- Send a controlled drawing (with revision and units) plus a STEP file, so the shop quotes the same part you designed.
- Name the material completely: grade, standard, form and condition, and say what substitutions are allowed.
- Put tolerances only where function needs them, and list quantity by phase: prototype, pilot, production.
- State finish, inspection, packaging and delivery needs up front, then compare quotes line by line.
- Use the one-page checklist near the end before you press send.
Why the RFQ decides the quote
A quote is a price for a scope. If the scope is vague, each shop fills the gaps differently. One assumes a standard 6061 plate and a loose tolerance, another assumes a tight tolerance and a certified bar, and you end up with two prices for two different parts. The lowest number is often the one that left something out.
A complete RFQ does three jobs. It lets the shop price without guessing, it makes quotes comparable, and it shortens the back and forth before the job starts. Questions will still come, and good ones are a sign the shop is reading your print. The goal is to remove the avoidable ones.

Step 1: Send a controlled drawing package
Start with a 2D drawing for every part, exported as a PDF. A shop works from the print, so the print needs to stand on its own.
What the drawing needs:
- Title block: part number, revision letter, units (inch or metric) and the date.
- Dimensions: every controlled dimension, with tolerances where they affect fit or function.
- Material and finish callouts: written on the drawing, not only in the email.
- Notes: deburr and edge-break requirements, thread callouts and any surface-finish limits.
- Revision control: if you are sending a revised part, include a short note on what changed since the last revision.
If you are not sure what belongs on a print, our guide to CNC drawing standards walks through it. For assemblies, add an exploded view with a bill of materials so the shop knows which parts are in scope and which are not.
The most common slip here is a revision mismatch: the PDF says Rev B, the model is Rev C, and the email refers to neither. Name the revision in the subject line and everywhere else.
Step 2: Add a STEP file, not just a mesh
Send a 3D model alongside the drawing. The neutral format machinists want is STEP, because it carries exact surfaces and edges. An STL is a mesh of triangles, which approximates curves and cannot carry true holes, radii or tangent edges the way a machinist needs. We explain the difference in STL vs STEP for CNC.
A good rule: the drawing governs tolerances and notes, the model governs shape. Say so in the RFQ, and say which wins if they disagree. Without that statement, a shop that finds a mismatch has to stop and ask.
Step 3: Name the material completely
"Aluminum" is not a material callout. A usable one combines the grade, the applicable standard, the product form (plate, bar, extrusion), the temper or condition, and any certification you need. A guide on writing material requirements for an RFQ lists the same ingredients and adds two that people forget: the edition of the standard, and the person responsible for confirming technical details (how to write clear material requirements for an RFQ).
Examples of the difference:
| Vague | Quotable |
|---|---|
| Aluminum | 6061-T6 aluminum plate, certificate of conformance required |
| Steel | 4140 steel bar, pre-hardened, mill cert required |
| Stainless | 304 stainless bar, passivated after machining |
Then write a substitution rule. There are three clean options: no substitutions, named equivalents only, or substitution only with your written approval. If you skip this, a shop facing a supply problem will decide for you.
Step 4: Tolerate only what matters
Tolerance is the biggest cost lever in a quote. Every tighter tolerance means slower cuts, extra setups, more inspection time, or all three. A drawing with a blanket tight tolerance on every dimension will be priced for the worst case.
A practical approach:
- Set a general tolerance in the title block that covers everything not otherwise called out.
- Mark the critical features: bearing bores, sealing surfaces, mating holes, datum faces.
- Tighten only those, and tie them to the function they serve.
- If you use geometric dimensioning and tolerancing (GD&T), state which standard and edition governs the print.
Datums are where assemblies fail, so check that they match how the part actually mounts. Our GD&T datum checks and the guide to perpendicularity callouts cover the common mistakes. If you are designing the part now, design for machining can take cost out before you ever send the RFQ: deep narrow pockets, tiny internal corner radii and thin walls are the usual culprits.
Flag the critical features in the email too. A short list such as "critical: bore diameter, hole pattern, flatness of the mounting face" helps the programmer decide how to hold and inspect the part.
Step 5: Split quantities by phase
A quantity of "100" tells the shop very little. Is it 100 once, or 100 a year? Do you need one sample first? State quantity by phase:
- Prototype: how many pieces, and how soon.
- Pilot or first run: a small batch to prove fit and process.
- Production: quantity per release and expected annual volume.
Shops often price one-offs and short runs very differently, because setup time is spread across the quantity. Ask for price breaks at two or three quantities, such as 1, 10 and 50, and you see where the setup stops dominating. If you are still iterating the design, say so: it tells the shop that you may send a revised drawing and that quick turnaround on a few pieces matters more than the unit price. Our note on rapid CNC prototyping covers that stage.
Step 6: Define operations, finish and appearance
List everything that happens after the part comes off the machine, or the quote will leave it out:
- Secondary operations: deburring, tapping, heat treat, press-fit hardware, assembly.
- Finish: anodize (type and color), powder coat, plating, passivation or bead blast.
- Masked or protected areas: threads, bores and mating faces that must stay bare.
- Appearance: are cosmetic surfaces important, and which ones?
For anodize, be specific. Hardcoat adds thickness that changes fits, so say whether the dimensions on the print are before or after finish. We cover that in hardcoat anodize thickness.
Step 7: Make inspection and documentation explicit
If you need paperwork, ask for it in the RFQ, because it affects price and schedule. Spell out which of these you need:
- Material certification
- Certificate of conformance
- A dimensional inspection report, and on which features (critical only, or every dimension)
- A first article inspection before the rest of the run
- Sampling plan for production lots
For a new supplier, one inspected first piece before releasing a whole run is a sensible control. The reasoning is in start with one FAI when outsourcing CNC machining. Say what "accepted" means: the inspection report, a go/no-go gauge, or a fit check on your assembly.
Step 8: Spell out packaging, delivery and schedule
This is the part most RFQs skip. It still changes the quote.
- Needed-by date, and whether partial shipments are acceptable.
- Ship-to location and any freight or carrier preference.
- Packaging: individual bags for cosmetic parts, foam, VCI paper for steel, labeling by part number and revision.
- Shipping terms: who pays freight and who carries the risk in transit.
- Release pattern: one lot, or scheduled releases over months.
If the date is flexible, say so. A shop can often quote a lower price for a relaxed schedule than for a rush.
Step 9: Name one contact
Put a single person on the RFQ who can answer technical questions fast: name, email, phone and typical hours. When questions go unanswered for a week, quoting stalls and the job slips behind the one that got answered. The best fix is a short list of questions the shop is likely to ask and answers ready before you send. Our list of machine shop questions engineers should answer before quoting is a good starting point.
How to compare quotes fairly
When the quotes land, do not sort by price first. Build a simple grid and check that every shop priced the same scope.
| Line to check | What to confirm |
|---|---|
| Revision | Quoted against your current drawing revision |
| Material | Exact grade, form and certification as specified |
| Quantities | Price at each quantity you asked for |
| Tolerances | No unstated assumptions or exceptions |
| Finish | Type, color, masking, thickness |
| Inspection | Reports and FAI included or priced separately |
| Tooling and fixtures | One-time charge listed, not buried |
| Packaging and freight | Included or extra |
| Lead time | Starts at order or at drawing approval |
| Validity | How long the quote holds |
A price that is far below the others is a flag to read the exceptions, not a bargain. Look for phrases like "per customer print" with no detail, a missing finish line, or a lead time that starts only after you approve a long list of questions.
Common mistakes that make an RFQ hard to quote
- Wrong or missing revision. The model and print disagree and nobody says which wins.
- Mesh files only. An STL sent in place of a STEP.
- Material by family. "Steel" or "aluminum" with no grade or temper.
- Tight tolerances everywhere. The price reflects the tightest number on the page.
- One quantity. No split between prototype and production.
- Hidden finish or inspection needs. They appear after the quote is accepted.
- No schedule. The shop assumes standard lead time and you assumed fast.
- Nobody to ask. Questions pile up in an inbox.
The one-page checklist
Copy this into your RFQ email and tick each line.
- Drawing PDF with part number, revision, units, tolerances and notes
- STEP file named with the same part number and revision
- Statement of which governs, drawing or model
- Material: grade, standard, form, condition, certification
- Substitution rule
- General tolerance and list of critical features
- Quantity by phase and annual volume
- Secondary operations and finish, with masking
- Inspection and documentation requirements
- Packaging, ship-to, needed-by date, partial shipments
- Named contact and quote deadline
Perspective
Most RFQs we see in concept are not bad, they are just missing a few lines. The part is clear in the designer's head and incomplete on the page. We build our own parts, like the E2 Kickstand for electric mini bikes, in the same shop that takes customer jobs, so we know how much a missing callout costs when a part has to fit and survive.
Our approach is to keep the machinist in the conversation. At Flying Chip Factory the person who designs and machines the parts is the person you talk to, with no sales intermediary in between. A question about a tolerance, a finish or a revision gets answered by the one who will cut the part, and a revision does not travel through a chain of people first.
That is why we encourage a short checklist like the one above, and then a direct conversation. Send the package, tell us what the part has to do, and we can talk through the details together.
Drake
Send your RFQ to the machinist
If you have a prototype, a short production run or a fixture or bracket to make, Flying Chip Factory machines in Athens, Alabama, and you work directly with the machinist who designs and builds our products. We take prototype machining, short-run production, and fixtures, brackets and support parts. Send your drawing package and STEP file through our machining services page.

Riders looking for a ready-made part can see our E2 Kickstand for the KTM SX-E 2, GASGAS MC-E 2 and Husqvarna EE 2, listed at $100-105.
FAQ
What is a machining RFQ?
It is a request for quotation: the package of drawings, models and requirements you send so a shop can price a job. A complete one covers geometry, material, tolerances, quantity, finish, inspection and delivery, so the quote reflects the part you actually want.
Do I need a 3D model, or is a drawing enough?
Send both when you can. The drawing carries tolerances, notes and revision, and the STEP model carries exact shape. Together they let the shop program the part without rebuilding geometry from the print.
How tight should my tolerances be?
Only as tight as function requires. Use a general tolerance for the whole part and tighten the few features that mate, seal or locate. Tolerances on non-critical features add cost without improving the part.
How many shops should I send an RFQ to?
A small group is enough, as long as every shop receives the identical package. Quotes are only comparable if everyone priced the same revision, material, quantities and finish.
What should I do if my design is not finished?
Say so in the RFQ, and describe what the part has to do. Quote a prototype quantity first, then release a production quantity once the design is frozen.
